Woman in the Window was my first experience of Fritz Lang‘s American films. It’s not often that a film splits my opinion so much.
On the one hand, it’s a story of a gentle, intelligent, middle-aged man foolishly chasing youthful fantasy. Edward G Robinson perfectly portrays a man driven to an arguably justified murder, and as he attempts to cover it up he finds himself in a spiralling web of deceit. It’s a simple but satisfying suspense film of Hitchcockian proportions.
On the other hand, there is that ending. To write about it would ruin the experience for someone who has yet to see the film, so analysis is difficult. Needless to say the first twist ending is dripping in pathos and would be a beautifully dark poetic finish, but is marred, for me, by a second twist which leaves a slightly corny taste in the mouth.
Fans of Lang’s earlier works should not expect any of the trademark expressionist flair found in his UFA and Nero films, but can expect a well-crafted, well-paced suspenseful drama which raises some interesting ideas and captures a great mood. Well worth a watch even if the last couple of minutes sours the film a little.







Oct 19, 2010 @ 17:47:10
Had to do a quick lookup about the ending – it has been YEARS since I last saw this movie (on VHS no less) but yeah the ending was kind of lame. After doing a little stealth research, the not-so-satisfying ending is so for good reason. Don’t want to spoil it for others …
Oct 19, 2010 @ 21:01:14
Yeah it’s hard to talk about without spoilers
I understand the production code reason, but to me it seems the first twist ending would have appeased the Hays office even more than the final twist. I guess the ending can be enjoyed much more if you think of it as a gleefully defiant “I can do anything I like as long as I add this ending” kind of way. Must have been tough for a master such as Lang to have to work within Hollywood’s moral production codes.
Either way I did really enjoy the film, I cant condemn it completely on the basis of those last 2 minutes.
Oct 20, 2010 @ 04:28:40
something similar happened with hitchcock and the ending of ‘suspicion’; cop-out ending not necessarily for production code but more “they wouldn’t dare do that” i love ‘suspicion’ but wished they had stuck with one of the scripted endings